# Email marketing rules: consent, soft opt-in and unsubscribe

URL: https://privacyboard.io/blog/email-marketing-consent-soft-opt-in-unsubscribe

Published 2026-11-14, updated 2026-11-14.

In the EU and the UK, marketing emails to individuals need prior opt-in consent, unless the soft opt-in applies: you got the address from a customer during a sale, you only promote your own similar products, and you offered an opt-out at collection and in every email. The US CAN-SPAM Act and Canada's CASL use different models, but all of them require a working unsubscribe that you honour quickly.

In the EU and the UK, you need someone's opt-in consent before you send them marketing emails, with one exception for your own customers called the soft opt-in. Every marketing email, with or without consent, must say who it is from and give a free, easy way to stop. In the US, the CAN-SPAM Act lets you email first but requires an opt-out that you honour within 10 business days; in Canada, CASL requires consent, which can be implied for a limited time after a purchase.

This guide explains the rules for newsletters and marketing emails, country by country, and ends with a checklist. It is general information as of 14 November 2026, not legal advice.

## Which rules apply to a marketing email?

Two layers of law apply in Europe, and it helps to keep them apart.

- **The ePrivacy rules** decide whether you may send the email at all. In the EU, this is Article 13 of the ePrivacy Directive (2002/58/EC), written into each country's own law (for example the French Code des postes et des communications électroniques, or § 7 of the German UWG). In the UK, it is regulation 22 of the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations (PECR).
- **The GDPR** (or UK GDPR) governs the personal data behind the email: your mailing list, what you track, how long you keep it, and the right to object.

Article 13(1) of the ePrivacy Directive says that email for direct marketing "may be allowed only in respect of subscribers or users who have given their prior consent". Article 13(2) then creates the customer exception, now usually called the soft opt-in.

A newsletter counts as direct marketing when it promotes your business. In November 2025, the Court of Justice of the EU confirmed that a free newsletter sent to registered users of a news site was direct marketing because it had a commercial purpose (case C-654/23, *Inteligo Media*).

## What does valid consent for email look like?

Consent under the GDPR must be freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous, given by a clear positive action. For email, regulators read that as:

- an unticked box or a separate sign-up form, never a pre-ticked box;
- not bundled into accepting your terms and conditions;
- not a condition of buying something;
- naming who will send the emails;
- as easy to withdraw as it was to give.

The UK regulator, the ICO, adds that consent cannot be passed on: an address bought from a list broker is not covered by consent the person gave to someone else. The CNIL says the same thing in plain terms: accepting general terms of use "ne peut pas suffire" (cannot be enough).

Keep proof. Record when and where each person signed up, the wording they saw, and the version of your form. If a regulator or the person asks, this record is your answer.

## What is the soft opt-in and when can you use it?

The soft opt-in lets you email existing customers without asking for separate consent, under four conditions taken from Article 13(2):

1. You obtained the email address **from the customer** yourself.
2. You obtained it **in the context of a sale** of a product or service (the UK also accepts negotiations for a sale).
3. You only promote **your own similar products or services**.
4. You gave the person a clear, free and easy chance **to refuse at the moment you collected the address**, and again **in every email** after that.

Two practical points trip up small teams. First, the opt-out must be offered at collection, on the checkout or sign-up form itself; the ICO says a line in the privacy policy or a later confirmation email is not enough. Second, the exception covers your products only: you cannot use it to send partners' offers.

What counts as a "sale" is still debated. In *Inteligo Media*, the Court of Justice held that creating a free account can be a sale when the free offer is a way to promote paid content, and that when the soft opt-in conditions are met, no separate GDPR legal basis is needed for sending the newsletter. The CNIL's guidance, updated in June 2026, still says the customer exception does not apply without an actual sale or service, even if the person created an account. If your sign-ups are free accounts, asking for consent remains the safer route.

## Do B2B emails need consent?

It depends on the country, which surprises many teams.

| Country | Email to a person at a company | Generic address (info@, sales@) |
|---|---|---|
| UK | No consent needed for "corporate subscribers"; sole traders and some partnerships are treated as individuals and need consent or the soft opt-in | No consent needed |
| France | Allowed without consent if the message relates to the person's job (CNIL example: software offered to an IT director), with information and an easy opt-out | Not covered by these rules, according to the CNIL |
| Germany | Prior express consent needed for email advertising to any recipient (§ 7(2) UWG), unless the customer exception in § 7(3) applies | Same rule |
| US (CAN-SPAM) | No consent needed, but no B2B exemption either: all CAN-SPAM rules apply | Same rule |

Even where consent is not needed, the GDPR still applies to the named person's data. You need a legal basis (usually legitimate interests, see our guide to the [three-part test](/blog/legitimate-interests-gdpr-three-part-test)), you must tell them where you got their address, and you must stop when they object.

## What does the GDPR right to object add?

Article 21(2) of the GDPR gives everyone the right to object "at any time" to the use of their data for direct marketing. Article 21(3) leaves no room for balancing: once someone objects, "the personal data shall no longer be processed for such purposes". Article 21(4) requires you to bring this right to their attention clearly and separately, at the latest in your first communication.

In practice, an unsubscribe is an objection. It can arrive as a click, a reply saying "stop", a message to support or a [privacy request](/blog/respond-to-data-subject-access-request). All of these count. Add the address to a suppression list rather than deleting it entirely, so that a later import does not put the person back on your list.

## What changed in the UK in 2026?

The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 changed PECR in two ways that matter for email. Both took effect on 5 February 2026 (sections 114 and 115 of the Act, commenced by S.I. 2026/82):

- **Higher fines.** The maximum PECR penalty moved from £500,000 to the UK GDPR level: £17.5 million or 4% of global annual turnover.
- **A soft opt-in for charities.** Registered charities can now email people who have shown interest in or supported their charitable purposes, with an opt-out at collection and in every message. The ICO says it only applies to details collected on or after 5 February 2026.

## How do the US and Canada differ?

**United States (CAN-SPAM Act).** No prior consent is needed, but every commercial email must:

- use accurate header and "from" information and an honest subject line;
- identify itself as an advertisement;
- include a valid physical postal address;
- offer an opt-out that keeps working for at least 30 days after sending;
- honour opt-outs within 10 business days, without charging a fee or asking for more than an email address.

The FTC's compliance guide, as read on 14 November 2026, states penalties of up to $53,088 for each email in violation. Purely transactional messages (a receipt, a password reset, a shipping notice) are exempt from most of these rules.

**Canada (CASL).** Consent is required, but it can be implied for a limited time: up to two years after a purchase or contract, and six months after an inquiry. After that, you need express consent. The CRTC says unsubscribe requests must be honoured within 10 business days.

## Do Gmail and Yahoo add their own rules?

Yes, and they work like a technical layer on top of the law. Google's sender guidelines require marketing and subscribed messages sent to Gmail users to support **one-click unsubscribe** (the `List-Unsubscribe` and `List-Unsubscribe-Post` headers from RFC 8058) and to include a visible unsubscribe link in the body. Google also asks senders to keep the spam rate reported in Postmaster Tools below 0.30%. These are not laws, but missing them sends your newsletter to spam.

## Which rules apply where? A comparison

| | EU | UK | US | Canada |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Law | ePrivacy Art. 13 + national law, GDPR | PECR, UK GDPR | CAN-SPAM Act | CASL |
| Model | Opt-in | Opt-in (individuals) | Opt-out | Opt-in (express or implied) |
| Existing customers | Soft opt-in, similar products | Soft opt-in, similar products; charity soft opt-in | No consent needed | Implied consent for 2 years after purchase |
| Unsubscribe timing | Without delay (GDPR Art. 21(3)) | Promptly, with a suppression list | Within 10 business days | Within 10 business days |

## Checklist: is your newsletter set up correctly?

- [ ] Your sign-up form uses an unticked box or a dedicated form, separate from your terms.
- [ ] You store proof of consent: date, source, wording, form version.
- [ ] Checkout offers a clear opt-out at collection if you rely on the soft opt-in.
- [ ] Soft opt-in emails only promote your own similar products.
- [ ] Every email names the sender and has a working unsubscribe link.
- [ ] One-click unsubscribe headers are on if you send to Gmail or Yahoo users.
- [ ] Unsubscribes, "stop" replies and objections from any channel go to one suppression list.
- [ ] Imports and purchased lists are checked against the suppression list before sending.
- [ ] Your privacy policy explains the marketing use, the legal basis and the right to object.
- [ ] Your email platform appears in your vendor list and has a data processing agreement.
- [ ] B2B lists follow the rules of each recipient's country, not just yours.

If you track privacy requests in Privacyboard, an objection received through your request form is logged with its deadline next to your other requests; you still need to update your email platform's suppression list yourself.

## FAQ

### Is a pre-ticked box valid consent for a newsletter?

No. Under the GDPR, consent needs a clear positive action. A pre-ticked box, silence or inactivity does not count, and the CNIL and the ICO both say so in their email marketing guidance.

### Can I email people who downloaded a free guide?

Only with their consent in the EU and the UK, unless the download was part of a sale or negotiation. Make the newsletter a separate, optional box on the download form, and do not make the download depend on it.

### How long can I keep emailing an old customer under the soft opt-in?

The EU and UK texts set no fixed period, but the GDPR principles of storage limitation and accuracy apply, so set a retention period for inactive contacts. In Canada, implied consent from a purchase lasts two years.

### Are transactional emails covered by these rules?

Receipts, password resets and delivery notices are not marketing, so they do not need marketing consent. If you add promotions to them, they can become marketing. Under CAN-SPAM, the primary purpose of the message decides.

### Do I need to delete someone who unsubscribes?

Stop the marketing, but keep the minimum needed (usually the email address) on a suppression list so you never email them again by mistake. The ICO recommends checking a suppression list before every campaign.

## Sources

- [Directive 2002/58/EC (ePrivacy Directive), Article 13](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32002L0058)
- [GDPR, Article 21 (right to object)](https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj)
- [Court of Justice of the EU, case C-654/23, Inteligo Media](https://curia.europa.eu/juris/liste.jsf?num=C-654/23)
- [ICO: How do we comply with the PECR electronic mail marketing rules?](https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/direct-marketing-and-privacy-and-electronic-communications/guidance-on-direct-marketing-using-electronic-mail/how-do-we-comply-with-the-pecr-electronic-mail-marketing-rules/)
- [ICO: Data (Use and Access) Act 2025, privacy and electronic communications changes](https://ico.org.uk/about-the-ico/what-we-do/legislation-we-cover/data-use-and-access-act-2025/the-data-use-and-access-act-2025-duaa-summary-of-the-changes/privacy-and-electronic-communications)
- [The Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 (Commencement No. 6) Regulations 2026, regulation 2](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2026/82/regulation/2/made)
- [ICO: Statement on the commencement of the Data (Use and Access) Act](https://ico.org.uk/about-the-ico/media-centre/news-and-blogs/2026/02/statement-on-the-commencement-of-the-data-use-and-access-act-duaa/)
- [CNIL: La prospection commerciale par courrier électronique, SMS-MMS et automate d'appel](https://www.cnil.fr/fr/la-prospection-commerciale-par-courrier-electronique-sms-mms-et-automate-dappel)
- [Germany: § 7 UWG, unzumutbare Belästigungen](https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/uwg_2004/__7.html)
- [FTC: CAN-SPAM Act, a compliance guide for business](https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business)
- [CRTC: Guidance on implied consent under CASL](https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/com500/guide.htm)
- [Google: Email sender guidelines](https://support.google.com/mail/answer/81126?hl=en)
